Product liability, mass tort and class action - defense: consumer products (including tobacco) in United States

Arnold & Porter

Primarily driven from its East Coast offices but comfortable handling cases throughout the US, Arnold & Porter has a national product liability practice, which has secured favorable results for clients when defending personal injury, property and economic damage claims arising from alleged defective products. Smoking-related cases remain a mainstay of the practice, and following on from the firm’s historical work for Philip Morris on tobacco cases, a team, led by Daphne O’Connor and John Massaro, is acting as national counsel for Altria in the defense of private actions (consolidated in several MDLs) and Attorney General lawsuits alleging damage caused by vaping products manufactured by Juul Labs. The team’s litigation capabilities have also recently been enhanced by the arrival of a six-strong litigation group, including experienced trial and appellate lawyer Frank Cruz-Alvarez from Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP, who all have strong product liability expertise. Clients also benefit from deep risk management and pre-litigation prowess, with Eric Rubel noted for his experience helping companies assess their compliance with Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) regulations, as well as handling subsequent product recalls and defending CPSC penalty investigations. Other recommended practitioners include Michelle Gillice, who also excels in CPSC-related work; New York-based Lori Leskin, who is adept at devising effective strategies for manufacturers of consumer products in complex litigation; and New York-based Anand Agneshwar, who co-heads the overarching product liability litigation group alongside O’Connor. All named practitioners are based in Washington DC, unless otherwise indicated.

Practice head(s):

Anand Agneshwar; Daphne O’Connor


Other key lawyers:

Eric Rubel; Lori Leskin; John Massaro; Frank Cruz-Alvarez; Jason Ross; Michelle Gillice; Dean Porter; Lauren Wulfe


Work highlights


  • Acting as national counsel for Altria and Philip Morris USA in private economic damages class actions, public entity actions, certain AG actions, and individual personal injury actions that have been filed across the country based on an e-vapor product manufactured and sold by Juul Labs Inc.
  • Representing Samsung Electronics America, Inc. against claims alleging that every natural gas-fired stove, range, and oven ever sold in the US are defective and emit harmful pollutants linked to asthma and other serious human health complications.
  • Acting as lead counsel for Coty Inc. in the defense against several individual and class action suits in state and federal courts arising out of the alleged presence of PFAS in certain CoverGirl cosmetic products.

Jones Day

With attorneys possessing core product liability expertise spread across the length and breadth of the country, including many first and second chair trial lawyers, Jones Day has strength-in-depth to handle a varied range and volume of cases involving a variety of product defects. Atlanta-based team head Stephanie Parker has deep product liability and mass tort expertise and is currently acting for core client RJ Reynolds in smoking-and-health litigation across the country. She oversees the firm’s nationwide strategy for the tobacco giant, which has recently secured notable jury victories in high-profile matters, including in ‘Engle progeny’ lawsuits in Florida state courts. The firm has also been at the forefront of the opioid litigation and continues to defend Walmart against novel claims based on public nuisance and RICO, among others. Chicago-based first chair trial lawyer José Isasi has been key to the firm’s successes in numerous tobacco-related jury trials, although his subject matter expertise extends to other product liability-related matters across the consumer space, as well as the pharmaceuticals and medical devices arenas. Other recommended practitioners include Los Angeles-based Celeste Brecht, who has consistently achieved success in jury trials; Atlanta-based trial lawyer John Walker, who has been extensively involved in RJ Reynolds defense work; and New York-based Theodore Grossman, who is highly regarded for bet-the-company litigation.

Practice head(s):

Stephanie Parker


Other key lawyers:

Theodore Grossman; José Isasi; John Walker; Meir Feder; Kristi Cercone; Bridget O’Connor; Mike Quinlan; Jackie Pasek; Celeste Brecht; Victoria Powell;  Gillian Schroff; Ramanda Luper; Caroline Murray


Key clients

Aldrich Pump LLC, Bestwall LLC, DBMP LLC, and Murry Boiler LLC


Chevron U.S.A. Inc.


Daikin America/Daikin Industries


GOJO Industries, Inc.


LTL Management LLC


Pennsylvania State University


R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company


Sherwin-Williams Company


Steris Corporation


Walmart Stores, Inc.


King & Spalding LLP

With product liability litigators spread throughout the country, including many with first chair trial experience, King & Spalding LLP has developed a market-leading reputation for its effective representation of numerous leading brands facing high-stakes, bet-the-company litigation. Under the overarching guidance of Miami-based Ursula Henninger and Charlotte-based Cory Hohnbaum, the team continues to represent RJ Reynolds in tobacco litigation, securing a raft of favorable jury verdicts relating to 'Engle progeny' wrongful-death cases. Led out of Atlanta by Geoffrey Drake, the firm is also acting as national co-counsel to TikTok, one of the defendants, in connection with several hundred high-profile lawsuits that allege harm to underaged users of social media. Work within the food and beverages sector is also a key strength, particularly on the West Coast, with Los Angeles-based attorneys Keri Borders and Dale Giali regularly defending clients in consumer product false advertising matters. In New York, John Hooper employs ‘sound strategies to manage product liability and mass tort litigation’, including matters within the consumer product field. Bruce Hurley in Houston and Shaila Rahman Diwan in New York co-lead the overarching trial and global disputes team, alongside Henninger.

Practice head(s):

Ursula Henninger; Bruce Hurley; Shaila Rahman Diwan


Other key lawyers:

Keri Borders; Morton Dubin; Dale Giali; John Hooper; Livia Kiser; Philip Green; Kathryn Lehman; Val Leppert; Julia Romano; Drew Bell; Patrick Price; Cory Hohnbaum; Geoffrey Drake


Testimonials

‘They take a very strategic approach to the litigation entrusted to them. They are hands-on and make good use of local firms to supplement their capabilities and drive efficiency.’

‘John Hooper is very energetic, engaged and interested in employing sound strategies to manage product liability and mass tort litigation. John is a good negotiator, and I recommend him as a lead negotiator for mass tort resolutions.’

Key clients

AUTOMOBILI LAMBORGHINI AMERICA


Beech-Nut Nutrition Company


Boehringer Ingelheim


Campbell Soup Company


Floor & Decor Holdings, Inc.


Foster Poultry Farm


General Motors LLC


GlaxoSmithKline LLC


Home Depot, U.S.A., Inc.


Kenvue (formerly known as Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc.)


KIND


Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC


Mine Safety Appliances


Nestle USA, Inc.


Organon


The Procter & Gamble Company


R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company


Snap, Inc.


TikTok


Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A., Inc.


Viking Group, Inc.


Walmart, Inc.


Work highlights


  • Acting as national co-counsel to TikTok in connection with several hundred high-profile lawsuits that allege harm to underaged users of social media.
  • Representing leading baby food manufacturer Beech-Nut Nutrition Company in litigation alleging that its baby food products contain dangerous levels of heavy metals, causing autism and ADHD.
  • Obtained a complete victory in the Ninth Circuit for The Procter & Gamble Company in a published decision affirming the granting of a motion to dismiss in a putative class action bought on behalf of California consumers who purchased Pantene Pro-V Nature Fusion shampoo and conditioners alleging that P&G, by including the language ‘NatureFusion’ and a photo of an avocado, represented that the products are natural, when, in fact, they contain non-natural and synthetic ingredients.

Latham & Watkins LLP

Drawing upon ‘outstanding knowledge’ and deep strategic intuition developed over many years handling high-profile product liability cases, Latham & Watkins LLP provides a ‘first-class client service’ to many leading consumer product manufacturers. Under the expert guidance of ‘master strategist’ Kenneth Parsigian and ‘dogged advocate’ Christine Rolph, the team is particularly noted for acting for Philip Morris in the ongoing defense of various cases brought against the tobacco giant by governments and insurers for healthcare recoupment costs. Boston-based team head Gwyn Williams has deep knowledge of state and federal consumer protection statutes, and regularly handles consumer class actions involving a wide variety of consumer products. Kegan Brown joined Lowenstein Sandler LLP in January 2024.

Practice head(s):

Gwyn Williams


Other key lawyers:

Christine Rolph; Kenneth Parsigian


Testimonials

They are very good strategists, brief writers, good with experts, good at managing local counsel and large-scale international product liability litigation.’

The team has outstanding knowledge and provide a first-class client service.’

They have deep knowledge and vast experience dealing with product liability cases, including foreign jurisdiction cases.’

Kenneth Parsigian: He is smart, always finds the key issues and provides clear resolutions. He is also articulate, experienced with lot of product liability cases.’

Kenneth Parsigian is a master strategist and tactician. He is unafraid of calling the hardest of shots.’

Christine Rolph is a dogged advocate for her client but also collaborative.’

Christine Rolph is as sharp as can be. She has incredible knowledge in complex things such as epidemiology and knows how to connect this with the legal side of the matter. It is a real privilege to work with her, and I learn from her a lot.’

Key clients

American Airlines


Apple


CCC Intelligent Solutions, Inc.


Clorox


Endo


Lands’ End


LG Energy Solution, LG Chem, and LG Energy Solution Michigan


Navistar


NCAA


Philip Morris International


Morrison Foerster

Led from San Diego by the ‘outstanding’ Erin Bosman following David Fioccola‘s departure for Proskauer Rose LLP in October 2023, Morrison Foerster‘s class action and mass tort group provides ‘business-oriented’ advice to established entities and growth companies on issues throughout the litigation continuum, from risk management advice and product recalls through to motion pleadings, settlement negotiations and representation at trial stage. The firm has deep roots in Silicon Valley and is regularly engaged in product liability mandates for manufacturers of hi-tech products. Bosman has noted expertise in the AI field, and is increasingly advising on product liability litigation involving AI elements. With a focus on the life sciences space, San Diego-based Julie Park‘s work extends to consumer products, where she is praised for her ability to ‘bring a human-centered approach’ to work, spanning product safety compliance and litigation. San Francisco-based William Tarantino is a key member of the team, particularly in light of his CPSC prowess, as is Purvi Patel in Los Angeles, who handles disputes for consumer-facing businesses, including privacy-related class actions brought against social media, e-commerce and tech apps.


Practice head(s):

Erin Bosman


Other key lawyers:

Julie Park; Tiffany Cheung; Purvi Patel; Alexis Amezcua; William Tarantino; Claudia Vetesi; Alexandra Preece Barlow


Testimonials

They provide extremely business-oriented advice that is sensitive to client’s priorities, risk tolerance, and the broader context of any project or dispute.’

The outstanding Erin Bosman and Julie Park are both incredibly practical, straightforward, honest, and they bring a human-centered approach to the advisory and defense work they do.’

Key clients

Thinx Inc.


Unilever


Work highlights


  • Successfully represented Unilever in the Ninth Circuit, securing affirmance of a district court order dismissing a putative class action challenging the labeling of I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter! Spray.
  • Defended Thinx Inc. in three putative class actions based on allegations that Thinx falsely represents its period underwear as safe and organic when the underwear purportedly contains per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) and migratory silver nanoparticles and was made with non-organic cotton.

DLA Piper LLP (US)

Leveraging a wide range of product liability experts spread throughout the firm’s extensive national network of offices, DLA Piper LLP (US) handles a significant range and volume of large-scale disputes involving a variety of consumer products. The group is noted for its one-stop-shop service to clients, which covers regulatory issues, government investigations and private litigation. The team is currently acting for Danone as one of the defendants in the heavy metals baby food litigation, including handling FDA interactions, a congressional investigation and putative class action and product liability suits filed throughout the US. New York and Los Angeles-based practitioners Loren Brown and Angela Agrusa lead on the civil litigation, recently obtaining an excellent victory before a California state judge. New York-based Colleen Gulliver is also involved in large-scale consumer class actions, including as it relates to alleged false advertising. Atlanta-based Christopher Campbell co-heads the mass tort and class action group alongside Agrusa.

Practice head(s):

Angela Agrusa; Christopher Campbell


Other key lawyers:

Ilana Hope Eisenstein; Loren Brown; Colleen Gulliver; Mary Gately; Lyn Pruitt; Isabelle Ord; Shannon Dudic; Lauren Grinder; Ashleigh Angeletti


Key clients

Danone


Nurture Financial Services


Sanofi


Bayer Corporation


TTE Technology, Inc.


Blue Diamond Growers


Work highlights


  • Representing Danone subsidiary, Nurture, in over 100 putative class actions, an AG action and several other product liability cases relating to alleged heavy metals found in baby food.
  • Leading the defense of Danone as one of the defendants being sued by a non-profit environmental advocacy group for its alleged contribution to the pollution crisis.

Greenberg Traurig LLP

Drawing upon a ‘deep roster of capable attorneys’, Greenberg Traurig LLP is well-positioned to represent manufacturers of a range of consumer products in big-ticket class actions and mass torts. Chicago-based Gretchen Miller has wide-ranging expertise in the product liability space, with work spanning risk management issues, CPSC interactions and large-scale litigation, where she is able to ‘deftly handle the complexities of multi district litigation’. ‘Fantastic’ Chicago-based attorney Francis Citera, who co-leads the product liability and mass tort practice along with Miller, is ‘an excellent legal strategist’. Robert Herrington and Stephen Saxl, based in Los Angeles and New York respectively, are also key to the firm’s success at handling class action cases, with Herrington regularly representing Samsung in false advertising and product defect claims involving consumer electronics and home appliances. Los Angeles-based Michael McCarthy is also recommended and regularly represents clients in the consumer electronics, retail, e-commerce, home appliance, transportation and homebuilding industries in consumer class action litigation.

Practice head(s):

Francis Citera; Gretchen Miller


Other key lawyers:

Robert Herrington; Stephen Saxl; Michael McCarthy; Eva Spahn


Testimonials

The firm has such a deep roster of capable attorneys, and those attorneys specialize in such a broad collection of topics under the product liability world.’

‘Gretchen Miller is one of the best outside counsel we utilize – not just in the product liability space, but overall.’

Gretchen Miller can deftly handle the complexities of multi district litigation.’

The fantastic Frank Citera is an excellent legal strategist.’

Key clients

Panera Bread Company


Eaton Corp.


Daimler Truck


Congo Brands


Prime Hydration, LLC


Himmel Management Co. LLC


Saks Off Fifth, LLC


National Foam, Inc.; Angus International Safety Group, Ltd.


Bird Global, Inc. (f/k/a Bird Rides, Inc.)


Albertsons Companies, Inc.


Ford Motor Company


Whole Foods Market Group, Inc.


Energizer, LLC


Sony Electronics Inc.


Mattel, Inc.


Red Bull North America


Advantage Logistics Midwest, Inc.


DevaConcepts LLC/DevaCurl


Target Corporation


Coty, Inc.


Archer Daniels Midland Company


Doosan Infracore International, Inc.


Dover Corporation


Courier Plus d/b/a Dutchie Inc.


Hyundai Motor America


Samsung Electronics America, Inc.


The Men’s Wearhouse, Inc.


Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois


Curallux, LLC


Work highlights


  • Representing Samsung in multiple putative class actions alleging false advertising and product defects involving consumer electronics.
  • Represented Lockheed Martin Corporation in a matter resulting in the Court granting summary judgment in favor of the company after excluding the plaintiff’s general causation expert, concluding that the expert relied on data that does not even show association.
  • Representing Qualcomm Inc. and Sony Electronics in cases brought by individual cell phone users against various cell phone manufacturers, service providers, and trade associations.

Herbert Smith Freehills

Co-led from New York by Gregory Loss and Benjamin Rubenstein, Herbert Smith Freehills advises manufacturers of a wide range of consumer products on issues throughout the litigation continuum. The team has also gained acclaim for handling international product liability matters, working well with local counsel to achieve favorable outcomes for clients. This is best exemplified by the work that both Loss and Rubenstein continue to handle for British American Tobacco, with both practitioners providing strategic advice regarding healthcare recoupment lawsuits, as well as other smoking-related matters in a range of countries, including South Korea, Canada and Brazil. Joseph Falcone also excels at handling cross-border product liability litigation, as does senior associate Maxwell Herman, who also has niche expertise in ESG litigation.

Practice head(s):

Benjamin Rubinstein; Gregory Loss


Other key lawyers:

Joseph Falcone; Maxwell Herman


Key clients

British American Tobacco


Samsung SDI Co., Ltd.


Work highlights


  • Acting as counsel for British American Tobacco (BAT), advising several BAT companies in multiple health care recoupment lawsuits in Canada.
  • Advising BAT and Souza Cruz, the largest Brazilian tobacco manufacturer, in defense of a healthcare cost recoupment lawsuit filed in 2019 by the Federal Government of Brazil, as well as advising Souza Cruz on numerous individual product liability suits.
  • Advising BAT Korea in connection with an action brought by the Korean National Health Insurance Service (NHIS) seeking to recoup healthcare costs that NHIS alleges were expended to treat Korean citizens who developed certain smoking-related illnesses.

Kirkland & Ellis LLP

Recognized as being the ‘epitome of creative lawyering’, Kirkland & Ellis LLP's practice is centered around its Chicago and Washington DC offices, and is particularly noted for its trial skills, regularly acting in bellwether trials and dispositive motions. Renee Smith is ‘superb at trying cases across a range of products’, regularly prevailing in jury trials and multiple federal MDLs. Robert Ellis is a ‘top-notch litigator’ who regularly defends high-profile companies in complex consumer fraud and product liability class actions. Washington DC-based Mike Brock has vast experience in product liability cases and is a key member of the team, which also includes Mark Filip, who splits his time between Chicago and Washington DC and excels in handling matters involving governmental investigations or enforcement issues.

Other key lawyers:

Renee Smith; Donna Welch; Jenny Levy; Hariklia Karis; Ragan Naresh; Michael Glick; Robert Ellis; Mark Filip; Mike Brock


Testimonials

‘They are the epitome of creative lawyering; they look at a case from all angles and put in the time and effort to understand the jurisdiction, parties, evidence, and legal standards thoroughly and better than the other side.’

Renee Smith is superb at trying cases across a range of products.’

Robert Ellis is a top-notch litigator.’

Key clients

Abbott Laboratories


AT&T


Chicago Cubs


Eli Lilly & Company


General Motors


Handi-Foil Corporation


Minerals Technologies


Syngenta


ZF-TRW Automotive Holdings Corporation


Mayer Brown

With litigators based on the East and West coasts and in the Midwest who have handled high-profile product liability class actions and mass torts, Mayer Brown is a popular choice among leading manufacturers across a range of consumer products for high-stakes disputes. The group often acts as national, strategic or settlement counsel on MDLs, and has notable procedural and substantive law expertise. The firm is also well placed to handle cases which leverage its white-collar crime and government investigations expertise to good effect. Based in Chicago, Michael Olsen is a well-regarded trial lawyer, who continues to lead on many high-profile product liability matters across a range of industries; he is notably involved in the asbestos litigation and American football concussion litigation. The firm also excels at handling appellate work; ‘whip smart, analytical, and quick on her feet’, Washington DC-based Nicole Saharsky is a key contact in this regard, regularly handling federal and state appeals and trial-level motions. Henninger Bullock and Daniel Ring, based in New York and Chicago respectively, co-lead the team alongside Olsen. Los Angeles-based John Nadolenco, who excels in handling consumer class actions in the technology and automotive spaces, is also recommended.

Practice head(s):

Henninger Bullock; Michael Olsen; Daniel Ring


Other key lawyers:

John Nadolenco; Nicole Saharsky


Testimonials

The firm has a unique combination of great writers, deep thinkers and practical lawyers. Dan Ring and Michael Olsen are the epitome of this.’

Key clients

The Big Ten Conference


Nestlé USA


Whirlpool Corporation


Weyerhaeuser Company


National Association of Manufacturers


American Farm Bureau Federation


Gerber Products Co.


Work highlights


  • Representing General Motors across a variety of product liability matters.
  • Representing 3M in numerous product liability and mass torts matters.
  • Achieved a major win for the multibillion-dollar window coverings industry through representation of the Window Coverings Manufacturers Association.

O'Melveny & Myers LLP

Leveraging practitioners in its East and West Coast offices, O'Melveny & Myers LLP has a notable reputation representing consumer products manufacturers in a wide range of product liability and consumer class action matters. Based out of New York, Hannah Chanoine excels in handling class actions for consumer packaged goods companies at both trial and appellate levels; she has had notable success in defeating claims alleging false advertising, and regularly devises strategies for mitigating class action litigation risk during product and label development. San Francisco-based Matt Powers co-heads the firm’s consumer class action group alongside Chanoine, regularly handling litigation for manufacturers and retailers throughout the consumer products space. Steve Brody and Sabrina Strong co-head the product liability and mass tort group from Washington DC and Los Angeles respectively, with Brody recognized as a ‘go-to class action product liability lawyer’ for work within the pharmaceuticals space.

Practice head(s):

Steve Brody; Sabrina Strong


Other key lawyers:

Hannah Chanoine; Matt Powers; Richard Goetz; Amy Laurendeau; Jonathan Schneller


Testimonials

‘Their main strength is the ability to resolve complex legal questions beyond the black letter law by providing unique, creative and bespoke solutions to the client.’

Steve Brody is a go to class-action product liability lawyer.’

Key clients

Kenvue (formerly the Consumer Healthcare division of Johnson & Johnson)


Colgate-Palmolive Company


Snap Inc.


BlueTriton Brands


TikTok/ByteDance


TeamViewer US, Inc.


Work highlights


  • Represented Kenvue (formerly the Consumer Healthcare division of Johnson & Johnson) in inning claims (on the pleadings) that the company unlawfully and misleadingly labeled its ‘Lactaid’ supplements.
  • Representing Kia America, Inc. in several wrongful death and personal injury claims in various state and federal jurisdictions alleging that inadequate anti-theft technologies facilitated car thefts, leading to reckless driving by thieves and auto accidents.
  • Representing Hill’s Pet Nutrition, a Colgate-Palmolive subsidiary, in three separate class actions challenging the marketing of its marquee brand Prescription Diet therapeutic pet foods.

Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP

Product liability work accounts for a significant volume of dispute resolution-focused firm Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP‘s docket of work, with the firm excelling in representing manufacturers across a range of consumer products. Many of the cases are high-profile class actions and MDLs, with the firm often securing national and regional leadership roles. William Geraghty has exceptional advocacy skills and has tried cases in state and federal courts involving a range of consumer products, including tobacco. As a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers, Kenneth Reilly has been heavily involved in defending the tobacco industry in class actions, while Kansas City-based Katie Gates Calderon, who excels in product liability litigation, also has deep regulatory expertise within the food and beverages space, regularly counseling clients on FDA and USDA compliance. Hildy Sastre co-heads the product liability team alongside Geraghty and Gates Calderon and is noted for her trial skills in particular. All named practitioners are based in Miami unless otherwise noted.

Practice head(s):

Hildy Sastre; William Geraghty; Katie Gates Calderon


Other key lawyers:

Tristan Duncan; Michael Mallow; Amir Nassihi; Kenneth Reilly; Sean Wajert; Annie Chuang; Michael Gallub; Jessica Grant; Patrick Oot; Homer Ramsey; Harley Ratliff; James Shepherd; Robert Simpson; Rachel Straus; Bruce Tepikian


Testimonials

‘Shook’s product liability team is extremely knowledgeable about the law, well versed in industry-specific topics and creative with their approach to tackling difficult cases. They bring a fresh perspective.’

Key clients

American Honda Motor Co.


Evenflo Company, Inc.


Ford Motor Company


Hyundai Motor America & Kia America, Inc.


Mazda Motor Corporation and Mazda Motor of America, Inc.


Nissan North America, Inc.


Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc.


Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP

‘Creative and innovative in approach’, Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP blends deep subject matter knowledge with exceptional strategic litigation prowess, and is a popular choice for leading consumer brands to handle large-scale product liability actions. As a ‘very effective litigator’, group co-head Diane Sullivan is regularly involved in bet-the-company litigation and has recently worked alongside the firm’s insolvency team to advise clients on exposure to potential tort and product liability claims through the so-called 'Texas Two-Step' bankruptcy legal maneuver. Recognized as a ‘good problem solver’, Theodore Tsekerides has also been involved in high-profile bankruptcy proceedings emanating from product liability claims, and worked with Sullivan in connection with the bankruptcy proceedings of J&J’s talc supplier, Imerys Talc America, which involved indemnity claims relating to talc claims liability. Washington DC-based individual Arianna Scavetti has gained a strong reputation advising manufacturers, including those within the food and beverages space, on consumer protection class actions brought by plaintiffs alleging false or misleading product labeling and marketing. Silicon Valley-based partner David Singh co-heads the product liability and mass tort group alongside Sullivan and regularly handles class actions including the defense of clients against allegations of false and deceptive advertising.


Practice head(s):

Diane Sullivan; David Singh


Other key lawyers:

Theodore Tsekerides; Arianna Scavetti; Pravin Patel


Testimonials

‘Creative and innovative in their approach. Know the company well and understand our products and technology.’

Diane Sullivan is a very effective litigator.’

Theodore Tsekerides is a good problem solver. He presents strategy, executes, and resolves.’

Key clients

Repsol, S.A.


ExxonMobil Corporation


PepsiCo


Burger King Corporation


Tarkett Sports


Nike


Johnson & Johnson


Dometic Corporation


Paramount Global


General Electric Co.


The Procter & Gamble Company


Sanofi, S.A.


Alibaba Group


Energy Transfer LP


Republic of Hungary and Magyar Államvasutak Zrt. (MÁV)


Work highlights


  • Successfully resolving a multi-jurisdictional, multi-billion dollar fraudulent conveyance and alter ego dispute in New Jersey and Delaware courts for Repsol, arising out of the pollution of the Passaic River in New Jersey.
  • Acting for Dometic in a lengthy series of multistate putative class actions in Florida federal court asserting billions of dollars in damages, alleging that cooling units in various Dometic refrigerator models purportedly contained a latent defect causing them to leak coolant and fail.
  • Defending Nike in a consumer class action in Missouri federal court alleging that the company’s advertising claims about its sustainable products are false and deceptive ‘greenwashing’.

Williams & Connolly LLP

Washington DC-based litigation heavyweight Williams & Connolly LLP has an excellent pedigree for handling a wide variety of product liability and mass tort litigation, acting for manufacturers and retailers across a range of consumer product types. The team is ‘adept at managing complex product liability litigation that has joint defense groups’, including large-scale MDLs and class actions. The firm is best-known for its trial-ready capabilities and boasts an impressive cadre of first and second chair trial lawyers. The ‘exceptionally smart and sharp’ Joseph Petrosinelli has excellent credentials for handling civil and criminal cases in federal and state court, and has secured notable high-profile victories in the pharmaceuticals and medical devices space. Notably, he is currently defending Gerber Products Company as co-defendant in high-profile litigation brought by plaintiffs alleging that high levels of heavy metals in baby food products causes childhood autism and ADHD. Heidi Hubbard is also noted for her strong trial skills and co-heads the product liability team alongside Petrosinelli. Thanks to the expertise of David Forkner, the firm also has a strong presence advising clients in the food, beverages and pet sectors on litigation, regulatory and risk management work, including in relation to class actions regarding alleged deceptive and fraudulent marketing and labeling.

Practice head(s):

Heidi Hubbard; Joseph Petrosinelli


Other key lawyers:

Edward Barnidge; David Kurtzer-Ellenbogen; David Forkner; Liam Montgomery; Neelum Wadhwani


Testimonials

The firm is adept at managing complex product liability litigation that has joint defense groups and is very good at dealing with the other counsel and acting as leaders.’

They find ways of winning in challenging litigation.’

Joseph Petrosinelli is exceptionally smart and sharp.’

Key clients

Gerber Products Company


Tyco Fire Products, LP


Autoliv, Inc.


W.W. Grainger, Inc.


Fifth Third Bank


Brown University


Cardinal Health


Intel Corporation


Work highlights


  • Representing Gerber Products Company in litigation involving the company’s baby food products, in which plaintiffs claim that baby food made by multiple manufacturers contained levels of heavy metals (lead, arsenic, and mercury) that caused childhood autism and ADHD.
  • Acting as lead and national counsel for Tyco Fire Products in nationwide litigation involving chemicals contained in aqueous film-forming foams (AFFF).
  • Representing Autoliv, Inc. in the ARC Airbag Inflators Products Liability Litigation.

Winston & Strawn LLP

Drawing upon the expertise of lawyers across the US with significant product liability expertise and also leveraging the firm’s overarching litigation pedigree, Winston & Strawn LLP is well-positioned to defend leading manufacturers and brands against high-profile consumer class action and product liability claims in the tobacco, oil and gas, and food and beverage sectors. Vastly experienced Chicago-based duo George Lombardi and Dan Webb are recognized for their versatility, with Lombardi having a particularly strong track record across product liability matters. In Miami, David Coulson has a formidable reputation for defending clients against consumer class actions, including claims in the food and beverages space. In Chicago, the ‘excellent’ Christopher Essig is noted for his ‘collegiate approach’ and is increasingly involved in cases brought against major consumer product companies. San Francisco-based Sandra Edwards chairs the product liability practice, which also includes Washington DC-based John Rosenthal, who is ‘one of the foremost thought leaders in e-discovery’, and Stephanie Clouston, who joined the firm’s Dallas office in June 2023 from Alston & Bird LLP; she is noted for her broad litigation practice.

Practice head(s):

Sandra Edwards


Other key lawyers:

George Lombardi; Dan Webb; David Coulson; Christopher Essig; John Rosenthal; Terrence Dee; Stephanie Clouston; Matt Saxon; Bryce Cooper; Jeff Wilkerson; Sean Suber; Patrick Hogan


Testimonials

They have amongst the strongest advocates you could want in a court room. They excel at big cases and MDLs.’ 

Christopher Essig is an excellent litigator and is very collegiate in his approach.’

John Rosenthal is one of the foremost thought leaders in e-discovery and an excellent trial attorney.’

Key clients

Monsanto Company


The J.M. Smucker Company


T-Marzetti


Abbott Laboratories


Albertsons Companies


Champion Petfoods


Motorola Mobility


Glasshape LTD


ASSA ABLOY


Unilever


Work highlights


  • Representing Abbott in state and federal proceedings involving numerous product liability lawsuits, alleging that cow milk-based preterm infant formula products cause a naturally occurring gastrointestinal disorder in premature infants.
  • Representing Monsanto Company as trial counsel for the Roundup product liability matters, including the first US jury trial, defending against allegations that the herbicide causes Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma.
  • Representing Albertsons Companies, Inc., Safeway Inc., and Lucerne Foods, Inc. d/b/a O Organics, in connection with the defense of litigation filed in the Superior Court for the District of Columbia alleging that their baby foods had excessive levels of heavy metals.

Bowman and Brooke LLP

Product liability and consumer class action work are core areas of focus for litigation firm Bowman and Brooke LLP. Alongside its market-leading reputation advising leading auto manufacturers, the firm regularly acts for consumer product entities in class action and mass tort defense work. Phoenix-based firm chair Paul Cereghini has excellent credentials in the courtroom, where he is particularly skilled at explaining often complex scientific and technological concepts to a jury. Cereghini’s impressive track record has seen him successful in bellwether cases within the auto space as well as claims involving a myriad of other products; he is currently leading the firm’s efforts for sports equipment company Riddell, Inc., which is a defendant in the highly publicized concussion litigation relating to American football helmets. Also based in Phoenix, Amanda Heitz has strong product litigation credentials, both at a trial and appellate level. Jeffrey Warren and Tori Levine jointly lead the firm’s consumer product practice group from Phoenix and Dallas, respectively, with Levine particularly noted for her work within the vaping and e-cigarette field.

Practice head(s):

Paul Cereghini; Jeffrey Warren; Tori Levine


Other key lawyers:

David Campbell; Amanda Heitz


Key clients

Riddell, Inc./BRG Sports, Inc.


3M Company


Glock, Inc.


The Husqvarna Group


BrassCraft Manufacturing Company (Masco Corporation)


Lloyds of London Insureds


Work highlights


  • Acting as national counsel to Riddell, Inc. in its highly publicized concussion litigation.
  • Representing Austrian firearm manufacturer Glock and its US subsidiary in defending putative product liability class actions in California and a product liability case in Arizona.

Cooley LLP

Led from Washington DC by ‘absolute rock star’ Matt Howsare, and also able to draw upon ‘incredibly talented attorneys’ in other nationwide offices, Cooley LLP‘s product safety group advises consumer product manufacturers on all aspects of the product life cycle, particularly in a regulatory and risk management context. Much of the firm’s success in this area can be attributed to Howsare, who ‘understands the politics and personalities of the CPSC at the most granular level’. Drawing upon the firm’s overarching technology sector expertise, the team, as well as handling work for established entities including Google, is also very adept at guiding fast-growing early stage companies. The firm is also able to draw upon broader litigation capabilities to handle disputes stemming from product recalls as well as enforcement actions brought by the CPSC. Lauded for his ‘excellent grasp of strategy’ , Washington DC-based Shawn Skolky is also a key member of the team, regularly acting alongside Howsare.

Practice head(s):

Matt Howsare


Other key lawyers:

Sonia Nath; William O’Connor; Shawn Skolky; Colleen Johnson


Testimonials

The team at Cooley has incredibly talented attorneys that are always available to help companies with urgent matters they are dealing with.’

The firm has excellent insights into the inner workings of the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Their expertise spans enforcement to advocacy and has resulted in huge wins for my company.’

Matt Howsare is an absolute rock star.’

Matt Howsare understands the politics and personalities of the CPSC at the most granular level.’

‘Shawn Skolky is fully capable of handling matters on his own and producing very significant victories. His grasp of strategy far exceeds most associates.’

Key clients

Google


SunSetter Products LP


Johnson Health Tech


Thorley Industries, LLC (d/b/a 4moms)


Work highlights


  • Defending SunSetter in Consumer Product Safety Act litigation.
  • Successfully represented Google, obtaining a motion to compel arbitration regarding the recall of the Fitbit Ionic smartwatch in March 2022.
  • Defended Johnson Health Tech North America, Inc., in a lawsuit filed in federal court in the Central District of California arising from the company’s recall of approximately 192,000 of its Horizon T101-05 Treadmills, which was announced on October 27 2022.

Dechert LLP

With a deep bench of product liability lawyers based out of the firm’s East and West Coast offices, Dechert LLP has strength in depth to handle large-scale MDLs and class actions centered around a range of consumer product defects; pharmaceutical products and medical devices remain the firm’s primary strength. Los Angeles-based litigator Jay Bhimani has significant courtroom experience in the field, and is acting in the bellwether jury trials for 3M regarding the combat arms earplugs product liability MDL. New York-based practitioner Sheila L. Birnbaum is also very effective at handling life sciences and pharmaceuticals cases in particular, and co-heads the overarching product liability team alongside Bhimani. Kimberly Branscome departed to Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP in February 2024.

Practice head(s):

Sheila L. Birnbaum; Jay Bhimani


Other key lawyers:

Mark Cheffo; Douglas Fleming; Hayden Coleman; Mara Cusker Gonzalez; Jacqueline Harrington; Paul LaFata; Rachel Passaretti-Wu; Will Sachse; Benjamin Sadun; Jonathan Tam; Emily Van Tuyl; Caroline Power; Marina Schwarz


Testimonials

The team has good technical and business understanding and knowledge of where to draw the boundary between risk and opportunity.’

Benjamin Sadun is a true star – a very rare type of lawyer with huge attention to detail and technical knowledge of various pretty complicated things (e.g. AI, data management, mobile apps industry).’

Key clients

The 3M Company


Abbott


AbbVie


Aylo (formerly MindGeek)


Bayer


BioAtla


GlaxoSmithKline


Easy Healthcare Corporation


Haleon


Johnson & Johnson


Moderna


Pfizer/Viatris


Prisma Labs


Purdue Pharma


W.L. Gore


Work highlights


  • Acting as lead counsel to GSK in connection with multidistrict and state court litigation alleging that Zantac causes cancer as a result of the formation of the chemical NDMA.
  • Represented Plum, PBC in the first-ever baby food heavy metals personal injury case.
  • Representing 3M and its affiliated entities in the Combat Arms Earplugs Products Liability Litigation.

Goodwin

Drawing upon litigators based in Boston, California, New York and Washington DC, Goodwin has a strong track record of representing clients in the tech and life sciences sectors facing product liability and mass tort litigation across the US. New York-based Joanne Gray is particularly effective at representing clients in heavily regulated industries, where her work encompasses litigation, regulatory compliance advice and risk management counseling. She is particularly acclaimed for her work in the food, beverages and dietary supplements arenas, regularly representing clients, including Herbalife, in product liability cases in federal and state courts. Boston-based team head Richard Oetheimer has extensive experience in defending product liability and mass tort claims brought against manufacturers of prescription drugs, medical devices, chemical substances, foods and dietary supplements, cosmetics and consumer products.

Practice head(s):

Richard Oetheimer


Other key lawyers:

Joanne Gray; Amanda Russo; Lauren Farruggia


Key clients

Confluent Medical Technologies


Herbalife International, Inc.


Kolmar Laboratories Inc. n/k/a Port Jervis laboratories and its parent company KDC/One


Work highlights


  • Serving as monitoring counsel for Confluent Medical Technologies in connection with the Cordis IVC Filter Mass Tort Litigation consisting of thousands of personal injury claims in a JCCP in Alameda County, California.
  • Advising Herbalife International, Inc. on developing and executing all product liability and mass tort litigation strategies for the company in the US, and advising on global litigation strategies regarding international product liability lawsuits.
  • Representing Kolmar Laboratories, Inc. in connection with talc mass tort litigation alleging exposure to trace amounts of asbestos through use of various loose powders manufactured by Kolmar with talc.

Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP

Combining ‘deep experience and knowledge of the law’ with a granular knowledge of the underlying subject matter, Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP regularly handles high-profile product liability matters, particularly in highly-regulated industries. As well as forging a strong national and international reputation for highly technical and scientific pharmaceutical cases, the team has also gained significant exposure to work in the tobacco space. From Kansas City, James Berger serves as national counsel to RJ Reynolds in the defense of cases concerning exposure to asbestos in cigarette filter material. Also in Kansas City, David Woods is well versed in regulatory issues and litigation affecting tobacco and e-cigarette companies, including acting as trial counsel in Engel Progeny cases in Florida. New York-based lawyers Robb Patryk and James C. Fitzpatrick co-head the product liability team, with both excelling at handling scientifically complex domestic and international pharmaceutical and medical devices matters.


Practice head(s):

James C. Fitzpatrick; Robb Patryk


Other key lawyers:

Theodore Mayer; Charles Cohen; Bill Beausoleil; Daniel Weiner; Rita Haeusler; James Berger; David Woods; Seth Rothman; Amina Hassan; Fara Tabataba; Brendan Franzoni; Tina Schaefer; Eric Blumenfeld; Kevin Braker


Testimonials

‘The complex cases that they handle on a daily basis makes the product liability team very well prepared.’

Everyone on their team has deep experience and knowledge of the law and all the technical and medical aspects required for crafting a successful defense.’

‘They have the unique ability to participate and co-ordinate highly complex cases out of the US with their outstanding experience and knowledge.’

‘Bill Beausoleil is a subject matter expert on the law and can always find the right answers, no matter how complex the subject matter.’

James Fitzpatrick is very adept at breaking down complex scientific subjects and working with expert witnesses.’

‘Charlie Cohen is an overall great litigator.’

Charles Cohen is brilliant, well-versed, detail-oriented, and success-driven. No stone goes unturned when he oversees a case, and we won’t stop until the client receives the best possible defense.’

Key clients

Ferro Corporation


Imerys Talc America/ Imerys S.A.


R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company


LG Electronics USA, Inc.


Work highlights


  • Acting as national co-ordination counsel and trial counsel to R.J.Reynolds in defense of cases concerning exposure to asbestos in cigarette filter material.
  • Developed a comprehensive defensive strategy and action plan for global mining company Imerys regarding its talc-related liabilities in the US.
  • Defending Ferro Corp. in multiple alleged water contamination cases involving 1,4 dioxane.

Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP

With a nationwide presence that was recently enhanced by the recruitment of a team from Bowman and Brooke LLP, including new offices in Dallas and San Diego, Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough LLP is increasingly well-positioned to handle cases across the US. ‘Taking the time to truly understand a product from inception to alleged failure’, the team, which is led by Mark Jones and Alana Bassin from South Carolina and Minneapolis respectively, is adept at handling work throughout the litigation continuum, often working across offices, ensuring clients receive a ‘responsive, business-savvy and cost-effective’ service. Alongside its acclaimed work for auto manufacturers, the firm has gained a particularly strong reputation for advising on asbestos-related matters for talc manufacturers, an area in which Baltimore-based trial lawyer Mike Brown is noted. Virginia-based Sandra Ezell, who was one of the new arrivals from Bowman and Brooke LLP, is praised for her ‘outstanding judgment on every aspect of a case’, including product liability matters, acting for manufacturers of consumer electronics products.

Practice head(s):

Mark Jones; Alana Bassin


Other key lawyers:

Mike Brown; Sandra Ezell


Testimonials

Nelson Mullins has a team focused approach to litigation where lawyers from multiple offices join together to provide exemplary work and strategy for clients.’

They have deep products liability experience and take the time to truly understand a product from inception to alleged failure.’

‘They provide responsive, business-savvy and cost-effective advice.’

‘Sandy Ezell has outstanding judgment on every aspect of a case.’

Key clients

American Optical


A.O. Smith Corporation


BIC


Colgate-Palmolive Company


Electrolux Home Products, Inc.


Johnson & Johnson


The Estée Lauder Companies


The Toro Company


Whirlpool Corporation


Work highlights


  • Acting as national trial counsel for Electrolux Home Products, Inc. in a case in Yuba County, CA that concerns a fatal apartment fire product defect case involving a Frigidaire refrigerator.
  • Represented Johnson & Johnson before a jury in California – the plaintiff claimed $500m in damages.
  • Serving as national coordinating counsel for Colgate-Palmolive Company in its talcum powder litigation – for which it has over 200 cases in court or pending – and as national trial counsel in relation to the same.

Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP

Primarily based in the firm's New York and Washington DC offices, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP's practice is accomplished at defending consumer products manufacturers, including those within the pharmaceuticals space, in large-scale mass tort and class actions alleging product liability infractions. The firm is also a key contact for MDLs, often assuming the role as national counsel. The team has continues to represent the Product Liability Advisory Council and the US Chamber of Commerce as amici in appeals involving important class action principles. New York-based Allison Brown has a key reputation in relation to both consumer class actions and product liability matters, and has gained notable dispositive motion victories (including Daubert hearings), as well as at final trial stage, including within the pharmaceuticals space. Washington DC-based team head John Beisner is also recommended.

Practice head(s):

John Beisner


Other key lawyers:

Allison Brown


Wilkinson Stekloff

With a team of ‘excellent trial lawyers and smart strategists’, Washington DC-based litigation boutique Wilkinson Stekloff has rapidly gained a strong reputation within the product liability field, frequently handling high-profile trials. With noted experience in the pharmaceuticals and toxic tort arenas, the firm is also adept at handling work for manufacturers of consumer products, including within the tobacco space. Name partner Brian Stekloff is ‘a smart, efficient subject matter expert and a great trial lawyer’, and regularly represents clients in high-profile matters; he recently acted for Altria in a bellwether trial brought by the San Francisco Unified School District alleging that it had engaged in a RICO conspiracy and created a public nuisance by hooking minors on Juul vaping products. As ‘one of the top trial lawyers in the country’, Beth Wilkinson was also engaged in the matter, one of many high-profile consumer class action and product liability trials she has recently handled. Managing partner James Rosenthal is also a key member of the team and has particularly strong insight into tobacco cases.

Practice head(s):

Beth Wilkinson; Brian Stekloff; James Rosenthal


Other key lawyers:

Keri Arnold; Cali Arat; Tamarra Johnson; Moira Penza; Ralia Polechronis; Matthew Skanchy; Max Warren


Testimonials

‘They are excellent trial lawyers and smart strategists.’

‘Brian Stekloff is a smart, efficient subject matter expert and a great trial lawyer.’

‘Brian Stekloff is a fantastic legal strategist and trial lawyer with impeccable judgment.’

Beth Wilkinson is one of the top trial lawyers in the country.’

Keri Arnold is a great trial lawyer and is collaborative in working with other law firms.’

Key clients

3M Corporation


Altria Group, Inc.


Bayer and Monsanto


Covidien and Medtronic


Work highlights


  • Representing 3M in Aqueous Film-Forming Foams (AFFF) Products Liability Litigation.
  • Acting as lead trial counsel for Altria Group and a number of its subsidiaries in the Juul Labs, Inc. Marketing, Sales Practices, and Product Liability litigation.
  • Acting as national trial counsel for Monsanto in litigation arising out of claims that its popular herbicide Roundup causes Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma.

Baker McKenzie LLP

With a core group of product liability and consumer class action lawyers primarily located on the West Coast, and broader commercial litigation resources nationally, Baker McKenzie LLP provides comprehensive coverage to consumer product manufacturers throughout the litigation continuum, with work spanning risk management advice, product recall matters, engagement with regulators and full-scale MDLs and class action litigation. San Francisco-based team head Mark Goodman has a good pedigree within the food and beverages space, regularly defending clients on false labeling and advertising consumer class actions, as well as acting in core product liability claims. He has handled numerous matters for US multinational food company Mondelēz, including recently successfully securing its dismissal as one of the defendants in a landmark environmental nuisance and consumer fraud action brought in relation to plastic packaging.

Practice head(s):

Mark Goodman


Other key lawyers:

Barry Thompson; Mark Taylor; Michael McCutcheon; Teresa Michaud; Jennifer Ancona Semko; Nancy Sims


Testimonials

They are very knowledgeable and resourceful.’

Key clients

Mondelēz Global


McCormick and Co.


Topco Associates, LLC


Subway


Yves Saint Laurent


Huntsman Building Solutions


Google LLC/Alphabet, Inc.


American Equipment Company


Barry’s Tea


Schnuck Markets


Namasté Laboratories, LLC, Dabur International, and Dermoviva USA


Work highlights


  • Successfully represented Mondelēz in a landmark environmental nuisance and consumer fraud action involving plastic packaging for food and beverage products and the labelling of those products and packaging.
  • Representing Mondelēz and Nabisco in a class action filed in the Northern District of California alleging that Mondelēz’s Wheat Thins products are labelled in such a way as to mislead consumers to believe the products contain only whole grains when they contain corn starch, which is a processed grain.
  • Representing McCormick and Co. in numerous Proposition 65 cases brought in Los Angeles.

Crowell & Moring LLP

Primarily located in Washington DC, Crowell & Moring LLP‘s practice is adept at representing consumer product manufacturers throughout the product life cycle, handling issues ranging from risk management strategies and product safety regulatory issues through to class action litigation. Drawing on deep insight gained from her former role as General Counsel at the CPSC, the ‘fantastic’ Cheri Falvey is pivotal to the firm’s success on the product safety regulatory front (including reporting obligations), and is often involved in subsequent product liability litigation brought by the regulator and civil class actions. First-chair trial lawyers Andrew Kaplan and Daniel Campbell co-head the mass tort, product liability, and consumer litigation group; both have considerable experience in jury trials relating to alleged defects in consumer products, including those involving misleading product labeling and advertising claims.

Practice head(s):

Andrew Kaplan; Daniel Campbell


Other key lawyers:

Cheri Falvey; Rachel Raphael


Testimonials

The fantastic Cheri Falvey has excellent credentials within the regulatory space.’

Key clients

BSH Home Appliances Corporation (BSH)


Olaplex Holdings, Inc.


Dentons

Drawing on the expertise of a deep bench of litigators, including many with significant product liability and consumer class action prowess, Dentons is well placed to assist consumer product manufacturers with all aspects of their business, from ensuring compliance with regulatory standards and managing product recalls through to evaluating litigation risks and defending against lawsuits. In San Diego, the ‘fantastic’ Sarah Carlson heads up the firm’s consumer product safety and advertising regulatory compliance offering, regularly going ‘the extra mile’ to acts for manufacturers, distributors and retailers of consumer products in litigation and regulatory matters involving the CPSC and consumer product safety laws. Based out of New York, team head Sandy Hauser has broad litigation experience in trial and appellate courts, including handling a notable volume of consumer fraud and false advertising claims. In Los Angeles, Michael Duvall is also recommended as a result of his defense work for clients from the food and beverage, diet and nutrition, and personal care and beauty product industries in relation to product labeling, false advertising and so-called 'greenwashing' class actions.

Practice head(s):

Sandy Hauser


Other key lawyers:

Jack Vales; Michael Duvall; Sarah Carlson; Belinda May


Testimonials

The team is able to synthesize information that is often times confusing to help drive appropriate decisions.’

Sarah Carlson is always a pleasure to work with while also being extremely effective at ensuring required deliverables are completed on time and to a very high standard.’

Sarah Carlson is fantastic and goes the extra mile to serve the client.’

Work highlights


  • Defending Pharmacia, LLC in a trial, where eight former employees of the Monroe School District allege personal injury claims, as well a single wrongful death claim, arising from alleged exposure to PCBs contained in caulking material and florescent light ballasts at the Sky Valley Educational Center and the Monroe Middle School.
  • Defending Monsanto Company, Pharmacia LLC, and Solutia, Inc. in a case in which two families of plaintiffs (including nine total plaintiffs) allege claims for personal injury and wrongful death arising from alleged exposure to PCBs contained in caulking material and florescent light ballasts at the Sky Valley Educational Center.
  • Led the defense of a class action against a leading cosmetics company alleging violations of California Penal Code § 632.7’s prohibition on recording or monitoring phone calls without consent.

Kelley Drye & Warren LLP

Kelley Drye & Warren LLP‘s bi-coastal team has ‘strong experience and knowledge of the consumer packaged goods industry’, and regularly handles class action litigation alleging violations of state and federal consumer protection laws, including as it relates to false advertising. In addition, under the guidance of Lauri Mazzuchetti and Becca Wahlquist, in New Jersey and Los Angeles respectively, the firm has also established itself as a go-to name in the market for handling Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) disputes.

Practice head(s):

Lauri Mazzuchetti; Becca Wahlquist


Other key lawyers:

Michael Lynch; Geoffrey Castello; Jaclyn Metzinger; Damon Suden; Whitney Smith; Glenn Graham; James Saylor; Matt Chakmakian


Testimonials

They have strong experience and knowledge of the consumer packaged goods industry.’

They are smart lawyers who are fair, knowledgeable, and pleasant to work with.’

Key clients

Quincy Bioscience


The Walt Disney Company


Kohl’s Department Stores


Gerber Products Company / Nestlé Healthcare Nutrition


Verizon Communications


ContextLogic, Inc.


Sotheby’s International Realty, Inc.


ActiveProspect, Inc.


Sunrun


AmeriFactors Financial Group, LLC.


Ladder Capital Corp


ADP


PC Richard & Son


Keurig/Dr. Pepper


Nu Skin


Arcadia Consumer Healthcare


QuinStreet


Hallmark


Cotton On USA


The Hershey Company


Work highlights


  • Representing Gerber in several actions alleging false advertising relating to certain claims made in connection with Gerber Good Start Gentle infant formula.
  • Secured the dismissal of two false advertising law suits filed against Ralph Lauren Corporation. The two separate class action lawsuits alleged that Ralph Lauren misrepresented the amount of Pima cotton contained in sweaters sold in its Polo Ralph Lauren Factory Stores.
  • Represented Hershey in a class action which asserted violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act and reportedly shared the data with Facebook.

McGuireWoods LLP

Led from Virginia by Justin Howard and Samuel Tarry, McGuireWoods LLP handles single plaintiff, mass tort, and class action product liability actions brought against a range of consumer product manufacturers including brands within the auto, electronic devices, and food and beverage spaces. The scope of the firm’s work runs the gamut from risk management counselling and product recall matters, through to notable litigation brought in state and federal courts relating to alleged product defects, as well as other broader consumer protection infractions.

Practice head(s):

Justin Howard; Samuel Tarry


Other key lawyers:

Benjamin Hatch; Jim Neale; Trent Taylor


Key clients

United Natural Foods, Inc. (UNFI)


Work highlights


  • Representing UNFI in litigation that includes state court personal injury trials, declaratory judgment insurance coverage matters, bankruptcy court proceedings and indemnity and contribution actions.

Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Co-led from Washington DC and Boston respectively by Thomas Locke and Joseph Orzano, and aided by litigators in other core offices in the Midwest and on the West coast, Seyfarth Shaw LLP provides a notable service to consumer product manufacturers including those within the cosmetics space, defending against product lawsuits throughout the US. The firm is adept at fending off putative class actions, including through a demonstration of lack of personal jurisdiction and through class certification denial, as well as providing advice on risk management strategies to prevent future litigation. Kristine Argentine heads up the consumer class action group from Chicago and is accomplished at defending companies across a range of consumer issues, including as it relates to the TCPA, consumer fraud and false advertising.

Practice head(s):

Thomas Locke; Joseph Orzano


Other key lawyers:

Kristine Argentine; William Prickett; Esther Slater McDonald; Giovanna Ferrari; Aaron Belzer; Renée Appel; Alexandra Drury; Connor Bateman


Key clients

JM Brands LLC


First Advantage Background Services Corp.


Pharmacare U.S., Inc.


Callaway Golf Company


American Armed Forces Mutual Aid Association


Personal Care Products Council


The Middleby Corporation


Work highlights


  • Defeated a $100m claim for class certification in a Fair Credit Reporting Act lawsuit against First Advantage Background Services Corp.
  • Representing Pharmacare against two nationwide consumer class actions alleging that Pharamacare’s Sambucol products violate the Federal Food, Drug & Cosmetics Act, and California, Missouri, New York, and/or Massachusetts consumer statutes.
  • Obtained scores of dismissals of product liability lawsuits filed throughout the country based on lack of personal jurisdiction and that plaintiffs could not pursue negligence, fraud, fraudulent concealment and civil conspiracy claims