In Sentinel Ins. Co., Ltd. v. Broan-Nutone, LLC, 2025
U.S. Dist. LEXIS 184988, the plaintiff (the Insurer), as subrogee
of the Assembly of Christians Gospel Hall Association (the
Insured), brought a products liability claim against Broan after a
ventilation fan allegedly caused a fire that damaged the
Insured's property. The Insured asserted breach of warranty,
negligence, and Chapter 93A claims under both Section 9 and Section
11. After discovery ended, Broan moved for partial summary judgment
on both the Chapter 93A claims, among other things.
The court granted summary judgment for Broan on the Chapter 93A
claims. In doing so, the court first drew an important distinction
between Section 9 and Section 11 claims, because the Insured had
not sent a pre-suit demand letter. As the court noted, Section 9
applies to consumer claims and requires a demand letter
before filing suit, unless the defendant does not maintain a place
of business or assets in Massachusetts.