On Sept. 12, 2024, the Appeals Court of Massachusetts upheld a
trial court judge's directed verdict of a plaintiff's
Chapter 93A, Section 9 claim in Simon v. Laundromax-104 Warrant
St., LLC.
In Simon, the plaintiff sued the defendant for
injuries allegedly suffered when using defendant's defective
product. The plaintiff's claims included breach of warranty,
negligence, and violation of Chapter 93A. The plaintiff's
warranty and Chapter 93A claims failed at trial as a matter of law;
however, the jury did find the defendant had been comparatively
negligent.
Even considering the facts in the light most favorable to the
plaintiff, the Appeals Court concluded that the defendant's
negligence did not amount to an unfair or deceptive act under
Chapter 93A, Section 2. According to the court, the plaintiff
had not presented sufficient evidence that the defendant's
negligent act itself “was or resulted in” a Section 2
violation. Relying on cases from the Massachusetts