At a Federal Trade Commission ("FTC") hearing,
industry professionals and experts debated the possible
anticompetitive implications of institutional investors holding
non-controlling equity interests in competing firms.
As described more fully in a
Cadwalader memorandum, the FTC hearing explored two possible
theories of competitive harm: (i) do passive index funds that
invest across an industry structurally disincentivize target firms
from competing and (ii) do such investments foster anticompetitive
collusion?
One panel was composed of industry professionals, including a
member of the Big Three (i.e., BlackRock, Vanguard and
State Street), a large union pension fund, several
investor/industry trade associations and several corporate
governance experts. The industry panel made several overarching
points, including that (i) index funds have become a driving force
for our nation's savers of retail investors and (ii)
prohibiting institutional investors from