Last week, three Capital One cardholders filed a putative class
action in the Eastern District of New York, Cohen v. Capital
One Funding, LLC,1 alleging that the rates of
interest they paid to a securitization trust unlawfully exceed the
sixteen percent threshold in New York's usury statutes.
The Plaintiffs seek to recoup the allegedly excessive interest
payments and an injunction to cap the interest rates going
forward.
The Plaintiffs seek to leverage the Second Circuit's
decision in Madden v. Midland Funding,
LLC.2 There are factual differences between
the current lawsuit and Madden. In Madden,
the loan in question was a nonperforming credit card account that
Bank of America's Delaware-based credit card bank had assigned
to Midland Funding, which sought to enforce the past-due
loan. In Cohen, the loans involve credit card
receivables from otherwise performing loans that have been
deposited into securitization trusts. The legal theory in
both cases, however,