Introduction
In Indian finance market, guarantee or comfort from promoters is
a crucial factor for creditors in lending transactions - primarily
because promoters of Indian companies have significant say in all
decision making and a large percentage of the economic ownership.
Under section 128 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, liability of a
guarantor is clearly co-extensive with the principal debtor, so a
lender can proceed against both guarantor as well as
borrower/principal debtor simultaneously.
Issue
However, when this was tested under the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (Code), NCLAT in Dr.
Vishnu Agarwal v. Piramal Enterprises Limited (Appeal (AT)
Insolvency No. 346 of 2018) (Piramal) took a
diametrically opposite view and held that for the same debt, claims
cannot be filed by a financial creditor in 2 separate insolvency
proceedings. Consequently, after the Piramal judgment,
lenders were unable to proceed against both guarantor and borrower
under