One of the hardest strategic questions for plaintiffs'
lawyers is when and how to introduce a jury to massive damages
numbers. In cases involving egregious conduct—like the $1.2
billion verdict against Alex Jones for defaming Sandy Hook
families—jurors may be eager to punish a defendant they
deeply dislike.
But in business disputes or patent infringement cases, for
example, asking for billions can backfire. Jurors may see such sums
as incomprehensible or greedy. The challenge is to advocate
aggressively for your client without alienating jurors, who may
themselves be struggling to make ends meet.
In a recent privacy trial against Google in the Northern
District of California, which resulted in a nearly $500 million
verdict, David Boies executed one of the best strategies for
tackling this issue early. David confronted the issue directly in
his opening statement. Before stating the ultimate damages figure,
he walked jurors through small,