On June 9, 2026, in Rondout Group Advisors, LLC v. Fresh American, LLC, the Massachusetts Appeals Court vacated summary judgment entered in favor of the plaintiffs on their Chapter 93A, Section 11 claim, concluding that genuine disputes of material fact precluded a finding of liability.
The plaintiffs were financial advisors engaged to assist with a company acquisition on behalf of the defendants. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants engaged in commercial extortion by threatening to derail the transaction shortly before closing unless the plaintiffs agreed to reduce their fees. The trial court accepted that theory and entered summary judgment on the Chapter 93A claim. The Appeals Court vacated that judgment, emphasizing that, in the commercial context, Chapter 93A liability based on alleged coercive conduct depends heavily on the surrounding facts and motivations of the parties.