The Bombay High Court (Bombay HC) highlighted the need to strike
a balance between press freedom and an individual's right to
reputation. It acknowledged the crucial role of investigative
journalism in society but cautioned against defaming individuals in
the process.
Justice Bharati Dangre emphasized that journalists cannot
justify publishing content that may incite hatred, ridicule, or
contempt towards an individual under the pretext of serving public
interest, even if they have a track record of exposing scams.
The issue in the instant case involved the respondent's
distribution of information via online platforms, which the
applicant alleged to be false, derogatory, and misleading. The
applicant filed for INR 100 crores in damages and a permanent
injunction against the defendant, as well as a prohibition on the
respondent from publishing or sharing any defamatory material about
the applicant.