Key takeaways
Express Grant of Leave to Appeal Required
The Court emphasized that leave to appeal against a procedural
order must be explicitly granted by the Court of First Instance
(CFI) under Article 73 UPCA and Rule 220.2 RoP. The CFI's
general statement referencing Rule 220.2 RoP ("subject to
appeal under the conditions laid down by the provisions of R. 220.2
RoP") was insufficient. Explicit language such as "leave
to appeal is granted" is necessary.
Inadmissibility of the Appeal
The appeal was declared inadmissible due to the absence of
explicitly granted leave to appeal by the Court of first instance,
consistent with the Court's previous ruling in Abbott v Dexcom
(UPC_CoA_5/2024, PR_APL_189/2024). This decision reinforces the
importance of procedural precision in appeals before the UPC.