On September 4, 2019, in Raincoast Conservation Foundation
v. Canada (Attorney General)1, Justice
Stratas of the Federal Court of Appeal allowed six applications by
First Nations for judicial review of the Trans Mountain Pipeline
Expansion Project (TMEP) to proceed and dismissed six other
applications, including by environmental agencies, the City of
Vancouver, and two First Nations.
The decision focused on section 55(2) of the National Energy
Board Act (the Act) which requires that a judge decide, on a
summary basis (based on written arguments) and without delay,
whether an appeal of a decision of the Governor in Council should
proceed.
The Act provides a complete code over project
approvals.2 “It provides for the National Energy
Board studying and assessing the project, the Board providing a
report to the Governor in Council, and the Governor in Council
considering the report and deciding one way or the
other.”3 4