In the case of Brown v. University of Windsor, involving the
University of Windsor and the president of its unionized Faculty
Association, the Ontario Court of Appeal had a chance to clarify
the situations in which arbitrators would have exclusive
jurisdiction over labour disputes. The claim involved allegations
that the University failed to satisfy requirements of the
Employment Insurance Premium Reduction Program ("EIPRP")
governed by the Employment Insurance Act, S.C. 1996, c.
23.
The requirements of the Act were not part of the
collective agreement, which gave rise to the Faculty
Association's belief that an arbitrator had no place deciding
the matter. The Court, on the other hand, found that if the facts
of the dispute, and not the legal characterization, fell within the
ambit of the collective agreement, this would be enough to place
the matter firmly into the hands of the arbitrator.