A recent decision from Ontario's Court of Appeal
(Swampillai v. Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Company of
Canada, 2019 ONCA 201) confirms a release signed by an
employee should only be overturned for unfairness with clear
evidence of a lack of fairness.
What Happened?
The employee was a labourer who became disabled and unable to
work. The employee applied for and received short term disability
("STD") benefits. When the STD benefits ran out, the
employee applied for long-term disability ("LTD")
benefits. His application was denied by the insurer providing LTD
benefits. The employee hired a lawyer to assist him with an appeal
of that denial.
The employee's employment was terminated a month later, and
he was offered a severance package. As part of the offer, the
employee was required to sign a release of claims. Included in the
release was a statement releasing claims to LTD benefits. The
release did not mention that the employee was still engaged in his
LTD