A business' obligations to its workers will depend on
whether the workers are employees or independent contractors.
However, a recent decision reminds us that, even where a worker is
a true independent contractor, this distinction may not preclude a
business being liable to third parties, such as customers, when the
worker does something wrong.
In Chieffallo v Ghuman o/a Appleseed Snowblowing
Service, the employer ran a snow removal business. The
plaintiff alleged that a snowblower operator assaulted her by
intentionally hitting her with the snow and slush discharge from
his snowblower, and using a highly offensive racial slur against
her.
The plaintiff sued the employer, rather than the snowblower
operator, in small claims court. The plaintiff did not allege that
the employer itself had done anything wrong; the only issue at
trial was whether or not the employer was vicariously liable for
the actions of the worker.