"Cause" for termination is a difficult standard to
meet in Canada. So what are your alternatives if you don't have
cause? Warning, suspension, demotion, transfer? In Haddock v. Thrifty Foods (2003) Limited and
Quadcam Holdings Ltd., the British Columbia Supreme Court
has recently said a demotion may not be a proper response.
Furthermore, a warning must be "current" to disentitle a
plaintiff to damages.
The Plaintiff's Declining Performance
The plaintiff was a grocery store department manager. He had
worked his way up to that position over the course of 16 years. For
the first 14 years of his employment, the plaintiff was a good
employee. But the plaintiff started abusing alcohol –
resulting in poor performance in the last two years.