A Canadian employee's attempt to invalidate an employment
contract failed, even though one provision in the contract, the
just-cause termination provision, was invalid. The Ontario Superior
Court of Justice (ONSC) relied on and upheld the portion of the
employment contract that provided short notice and relatively low
pay, the without-cause termination provision, because the employee
was fired without cause.
When just cause for dismissal exists at common law, which is a
high standard, an employer can terminate the employment
relationship without providing common-law notice or pay in lieu of
notice. However, depending on the nature of the employee
misconduct, the dismissed employee may still be entitled to
statutory termination payments under the Employment Standards Act,
2000 (ESA). This is because the threshold of misconduct required to
justify denial of the statutory termination payments, commonly
known as "willful misconduct," is higher than the
common-law