It has long been the law in Alberta that work site parties
convicted of offences under the Occupational Health and Safety Act,
Regulations or Code could spend time in jail. Until recently,
however, this had never happened. Alberta courts have relied
instead on fines and/or creative sentencing.
In R. v Haya Homes Ltd., Sahib Contracting Inc. and Sukwinder
Singh Nagra, Judge Michelle Doyle of the Alberta Provincial Court
imposed a period of incarceration on a family business owner for
creating a dangerous work environment that resulted in the death of
a day labourer.
Mr. Nagra, the owner and operator of Sahib Contracting, was
charged under the Criminal Code for criminal negligence causing
death (also a rarity in Alberta), but plead guilty to a charge
under s. 2 of the OHS Act for "failing to take reasonable care
to protect the health and safety" of the deceased worker,
Frederick Tomyn. At the summary disposition, the guilty plea and an
agreed statement of facts as