Asserting and establishing just cause when faced with an action
of wrongful dismissal is a difficult and often unsuccessful avenue
for employers. Establishing an employee has committed acts or
omitted to perform the responsibilities of their position therefore
disentitling them to common law reasonable notice is a high burden.
The height of the legal burden will differ depending on the type of
cause asserted, but it remains an uphill battle for employers
regardless of whether the cause is framed as insubordination,
theft, fraud or a combination of issues.
A decision from the Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta
provides a useful illustration of how cumulative improper acts can
amount to just cause. The decision, Molloy v. EPCOR Utilities
Inc. involved an employee that was dismissed in 2009
following an investigation into complaints of breaches of the
employer's Ethics and Respectful Workplace Policies and
improper conduct with another utility company.