As first published in the Australian Health Law
Bulletin, September 2017, p 137-139
Abstract
In a recent decision of the New South Wales Court of Appeal, the
basis on which a trial judge could properly choose between
competing expert opinions on mental harm was addressed. Perhaps of
broader interest however was the court's focus on loss of
earning capacity, in particular the principle that once a plaintiff
has established a loss of earning capacity, the onus of
demonstrating a failure to exercise any residual earning capacity
lies on the defendant
Background
The matter of Sorbello v South Western Sydney Local Health
Network; Sultan v South Western Sydney Local Health
Network1 attracted some attention
for the quantum of damages awarded to Ms Sorbello at trial for
mental harm following the injuries sustained by her son Joseph he
had suffered severe injury as the result of oxygen deprivation
during his birth at Bankstown Hospital (NSW) in 2008. It was