An aircraft owner and pilot sued by his passengers for injuries
in a crash was denied coverage under the insurance issued to
avionics manufacturer Garmin International. The owner's
argument for coverage was based on an agreement by Garmin to sell
at a discount a new product, a G900X, if the owner would allow
Garmin access to the airplane to obtain installation data for a
user manual. The G900X had been installed prior to the crash.
The aircraft owner argued that Garmin's insurance policy
extended to joint ventures in which Garmin was involved, and that
his arrangement to allow Garmin access to the airplane to access
data in return for a discount constituted such a joint venture. The
Tenth Circuit affirmed the trial court's grant of summary
judgment against the owner, however, holding that a joint venture
involving Garmin would be an insured under the policy only if
Garmin had an ownership interest in the entity, had been obliged to
provide insurance, or had exerted