Originally published in Habitat Magazine in January
2018
Does the Business Judgment Rule allow a board
to violate its own rules? That was the main question in Fred
Dicker v. Glen Oaks Vil. Owners Inc.
Glen Oaks Village is a Queens cooperative with more than 2,900
garden-style apartments in 134 two-story buildings spread over 110
acres. The co-op had a rule: a second-floor owner could construct a
balcony if the first-floor owner granted permission. The rule was
probably adopted because light and air in the first-floor
apartments would be affected by construction of a balcony upstairs.
The board could also modify or waive the rule on a caseby- case
basis at any time.
When a second-floor owner, Anne Haffey, asked Fred Dicker for
permission to build a terrace above his apartment, he refused.
Dicker is an investor who owns eight units but does not live in any
of them. The board stepped in, resolving that, in situations where
a first-floor apartment is owned by an