An unpaid subcontractor may attempt to hold a property owner responsible for work performed on the owner’s property, even though the subcontractor’s contract is with the general contractor. The fact that the owner benefited from that work, however, generally does not, by itself, create an obligation to pay for it.
One theory an unpaid subcontractor may pursue is quantum meruit, which, under certain circumstances, permits recovery of the reasonable value of services performed. However, this theory has an important limitation: a party generally cannot recover under quantum meruit for work governed by a valid written contract.
This limitation is particularly significant in construction projects, where subcontractors typically contract with general contractors rather than property owners. The subcontractor therefore ordinarily looks to the general contractor, with whom it contracted, for payment for its work. As the Appellate Division, Second Department, explained in Sybelle Carpet & L