In a recent decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit ("CAFC") the supervising court for the Court of
Federal Claims and the Boards of Contract Appeals, among others)
clarified important legal principles concerning the federal
government's duty of good faith and fair dealing and its
responsibility for differing site conditions. Metcalf Construction
Company, Inc. v. United States controls disputes with the federal
government and also provides authority and rationale useful to
contractors in disputes with any project owner, public or
private.
In October 2002, Metcalf Construction, a small business based in
Hawaii, was awarded a $48 million contract to design and build 212
housing units for the U.S. Navy on a Marine Corps base in Hawaii.
Saying the project did not go smoothly is an understatement.
Metcalf's performance was hindered and delayed by unanticipated
soil conditions and other issues made worse by the Navy's
failure to administer the contract