In 2008, a crane operator and a construction worker were
killed when a construction crane collapsed on the east side of
Manhattan. The decedents' estates brought suit against the
project owner, the construction manager and the crane operator. The
three construction defendants asserted cross-claims against the
City of New York seeking indemnification and contribution on the
grounds that the City failed in its duty to keep the construction
site safe.
The trial court dismissed the cross-claims against the City. The
New York State Supreme Court Appellate Division First Department
unanimously affirmed the trial court. The Appellate Court held that
the City of New York did not have to indemnify the three defendants
in the wrongful death suits arising from a deadly crane collapse
because the plaintiffs had not shown a special relationship between
the City and the three defendants that would give rise to a
special duty. The Court distinguished between the exercise of