This week we're concluding our trip through the
Justice-by-Justice oral argument analytics data to determine
whether it's possible to predict when a particular Justice is
dissenting (although Justice Michael Burke replaced Justice Thomas
earlier this year, there is too little data so far to reach any
conclusions about his arguments). Today and tomorrow,
we're looking at Justice Neville's numbers, first for civil
cases, then for criminal cases.
So far, Justice Neville has not been particularly active in
civil cases. When he's voting with the majority to
affirm, he averages 0.1 questions to appellants and 0.05 to
appellees. When he's joining the majority in an
affirmance, it's 0.28 to appellees, 0.12 to appellants.
When he's in the majority of a split decision, he averages 0.13
to appellees and none to appellants.