On May 28, the Supreme Court decided Home Depot U.S.A. v.
Jackson, 17-1471 (2019), ruling 5–4 that third-party
counterclaim defendants may not remove class actions from state to
federal court. The decision, besides keeping in state court certain
class actions that otherwise could be removed to federal court, is
noteworthy for the highly unusual composition of the majority, in
which the four justices comprising the so-called liberal wing of
the Court, banded together with Justice Thomas, who authored the
majority opinion.
The case began as a debt-collection action that Citibank brought
against respondent Jackson for charges incurred on a Home Depot
credit card. Jackson counterclaimed against Citibank, and also
asserted a third-party class-action claim against Home Depot on
behalf of an alleged class of those victimized by a purported Home
Depot scheme to induce homeowners to buy water treatment systems at
inflated prices. Citibank dismissed its claims against