In reversing the Fifth Circuit and overturning precedent in
other circuits, the Supreme Court struck down the "wholly
groundless" exception. It held that such an exception is
inconsistent with and not found in the Federal Arbitration Act.
On January 8, 2019, in Henry Schein, Inc. v. Archer and
White Sales, Inc., Case No. 17-1271, the Supreme Court of the
United States issued a unanimous, groundbreaking opinion concerning
whether a court may override a contract delegating the
arbitrability of a matter to an arbitrator. Before this decision,
there was a split among certain circuit courts, in which some held
that the district courts did have jurisdiction to decide the
threshold question of arbitrability of a dispute (Fourth Circuit;
Fifth Circuit; Sixth Circuit; and Federal Circuit) and certain
circuit courts held otherwise (Tenth Circuit and Eleventh Circuit).
In reconciling that inconsistency, the Supreme Court has now held
that courts may not override a contract