Staying with the Kentucky theme, that state's Supreme Court
held that insurers could not deny claims for PIP medical expenses
based on a "paper" medical review. Government
Employees Ins. Co. v. Sanders, Case no. 2018 WL 5732087 (Ky.
Nov. 1, 2018). In a paean to its Kentucky roots, the court quoted
Davy Crockett on raccoon hunting to find that the trial court and
attorneys were "barking up the wrong tree."
Kentucky statute requires payment of basic reparations benefits
without regard to fault, up to a maximum of $10,000. The statute
expresses when insurers may deny benefits, but because it says
nothing about denying claims based on review of medical records or
even on an exam, the Sanders court held that claims for
medical expenses could not be denied based on that review. The
Kentucky Supreme Court was careful to identify several other
reasons expressed in the statute for denying claims.