Two federal courts recently dismissed defamation claims brought
against the New York Times and the Kansas City
Star, finding the subject articles employed standard
investigative journalism techniques that immunized the newspapers
from liability under state defamation laws.
In Croce v. New York Times
Co., No. 18-4158 (6th Cir. July 17, 2019), the 6th Circuit
upheld the dismissal of an Ohio State University cancer
researcher's defamation claim, finding that a "reasonable
reader" would interpret the article as presenting both sides
of the controversy. The suit arose after the Times
published an article examining Dr. Carlo Croce's cancer
research in the context of a broader piece about the inherent
conflicts present when large research institutions reap millions of
dollars in grant money for "star" researchers, and then
are put in the position of investigating those researchers'
methods.