On September 4, Judge Rogers of the Northern District of
California granted defendants' motion to strike plaintiffs'
second renewed motion for class certification. The motion was filed
by indirect purchaser plaintiffs in this lithium ion batteries
antitrust litigation. The "second renewed motion," which
was in fact a third motion for class certification, cited Rule
23(c)(1)(C) as authority. Plaintiffs did not seek leave to file
this third motion.
In striking the motion, the district court relied heavily upon
the importance of adhering to scheduling orders. Although a second
motion for class certification was accepted by the district court,
the court anticipated that that motion would be the final such
certification motion. "While the Court's scheduling order
was silent as to the filing of a third class certification
motion, the entire case plan depended upon class certification
being settled once the Court issued its decision on the second
class certification