When trial lawyers tell war stories, direct examination is never the star. The stories are about the opening that landed, the cross that broke the witness, the closing that tied everything together. Where cross is sexy, direct wears sandals with socks. It is treated as the necessary middle act, important in theory but unremarkable in memory. That is a mistake. Direct examination is not merely the part of trial where the lawyer steps aside and the witness takes over. It is one of the most important forms of advocacy. Yet many lawyers do it poorly, usually because they mistake the rule against leading for a command to relinquish witness control.
When I first began trying cases, cross-examination seemed easier to master than direct. Cross gives the comfort of structure. If I prepared carefully enough, including by having impeachment at the ready for every fact of consequence, then I controlled the sequence of testimony, defined the topics to be covered, and could highlight the themes of