In Short
The Situation: Under the Class Action Fairness
Act, the Department of Justice may object to federal class action
settlements it believes are unfair or inequitable to unnamed class
members.
The Result: In the past year, federal officials
have increasingly objected to proposed class settlements in federal
court.
Looking Ahead: Class-action litigants should
carefully tailor the terms of class settlements to avoid—or,
if necessary, withstand—governmental objections.
Both the Class Action Fairness Act of 2005 ("CAFA")
and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)(2)'s recent
amendments contemplate heightened scrutiny of potential inequities
in class settlements in federal court. CAFA requires litigants to
provide notice of class settlements to the U.S. Department of
Justice ("DOJ"). DOJ interprets this requirement to
enable it to file statements of interest (otherwise known as
objections) against proposed settlements to prevent consumer