Two consumers walked into supermarkets on a mission to find
"nutritious, healthy snacks" that "would not likely
increase [their] risk of disease" and later walked out with
Fruit Bowls in Gel, Fruit Bowls in Juice, Canned Fruit in Juice,
Canned Fruit in Heavy Syrup, Canned Fruit in Light Syrup, and
Canned Fruit Juice. Perhaps those wouldn't be your first
choices, given that mission statement, but the consumers were
swayed, in part, by Dole's "promise to provide everyone,
everywhere with good nutrition."
The consumers later learned – perhaps after consulting
with their nutritionists or their legal counsel – that the
products were high in added sugar and that the consumption of too
much added sugar may not be good for you. They then sued Dole
alleging, among other things, that Dole had broken its promise and
that the company's claims amounted to false advertising. In
response, Dole argued that its claims were mere puffery. The
court's analysis is instructive in