All but a handful of courts find that companies disclosing
privileged communications or protected work product to the
government waive both of those protections. Courts properly
analyzing waiver rules also recognize that disclosing historical
facts does not cause a waiver – because historical facts are
not privileged.
In two related cases, Judge Francis of the Southern District of
New York dealt with the intersection of these basic principles. In
In re Weatherford International Securities Litigation, No.
11 Civ. 1646 (LAK) (JCF), 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 170559 (S.D.N.Y.
Nov. 5, 2013), Weatherford retained Latham & Watkins and Davis
Polk to conduct two separate corporate investigations into material
weaknesses in the company's internal controls over financial
reporting. The court acknowledged that both investigations deserved
work product protection. However, the court also found that the
company waived its privilege and fact (but not opinion) work
product protection by