Introduction
Since the Florida Supreme Court’s decision in Binger v. King Pest Control, 401 So. 2d 1310 (Fla. 1981), the case has served as a foundational precedent in the realm of civil discovery, particularly regarding expert witness disclosure and trial management. However, as highlighted in a recent judicial opinion from Florida’s Sixth District Court of Appeals (Crecelius v. Rizzitano, 2026 WL 555031 (Fla 6th DCA 2026)), subsequent interpretations by other Florida district courts have expanded and, arguably, misapplied the Binger holding in ways that undermine the objectives of discovery rules. This analysis explores the original Binger decision, its intended scope, subsequent judicial expansions, and the implications for trial courts’ authority to enforce pretrial discovery deadlines.