Early on in law school we were taught the virtues of alternate
pleading. Different theories against the same defendant, or
different theories against different defendants, were perfectly
acceptable even if inconsistent.
There is something counterintuitive about that. It seems to lift
the veil in front of the law, revealing it to be an opportunistic
enterprise more wedded to winning than reality. And then
there's that old story told by renowned Texas trial lawyer Race
Horse Haynes about defending against a dog bite case with alternate
theories: your injury isn't so bad, you provoked the dog, it
was another dog, and, oh by the way, my client doesn't even own
a dog. That sort of nimbleness can come at the expense of
credibility.