While the impact of Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank
International1 on early case strategy has been explored
extensively, few commentators have addressed how Alice may impact
jury trials.
This article seeks to address this issue, including how Alice
provides a separate invalidity defense that bypasses certain
patent-friendly validity doctrines, such as motivation to combine
and the secondary considerations of nonobviousness and how
practitioners might tailor jury instructions, verdict forms, and
trial evidence when an Alice defense will be presented to the
jury.
Background: Alice and Berkheimer
In a progression of seminal opinions culminating in Alice Corp.
Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank International, the U.S. Supreme Court
rejuvenated the often-ignored defense of patent ineligibility under
Section 101. Courts and patent practitioners have attempted to
apply the Supreme Court's guidance in litigation, with one
notable consequence being the prevalence of early