Last week, in
Laerdal Medical Corp. v. ITC, No. 17-2445 (Fed. Cir. Dec.
7, 2018), the Federal Circuit held that, once the ITC institutes an
investigation, it cannot reconsider the adequacy of the complaint.
Normally, that does not matter because the ITC can rule against the
complainant on the merits. But, if the respondents default, the
Commission has to rule against them and go to the relief phase.
Laerdal filed a complaint against a number of respondents, and
the Commission instituted an investigation based on trade dress,
patent, copyright, and trademark claims. No respondent answered.
After a few warnings, the ALJ issued an initial determination that
the respondents were in default, and the Commission did not review
the decision. Laerdal then asked for a limited exclusion order. The
Commission issued exclusion orders based on the patent and
trademark claims but not the trade dress and copyright claims,
finding the complaint's allegations as to those