The Minnesota Supreme Court issued its long-anticipated ruling
regarding the requirements an insured must prove in order to
satisfy the state's first party bad faith statute. Minn.
Stat. § 604.18 creates a direct cause of action by an insured
against its insurer if the insurer fails to act in good faith.
Under section 604.18, subd. 2, a court may award costs to an
insured against an insurer, provided the insured can make certain
showings. The court held that the statute's two-prong test
requires that: (1) the insured prove, under an objective analysis,
that after conducting an investigation and fairly evaluating the
evidence, a reasonable insurer would not have denied the
insured's claim; and (2) the insured prove, under a
subjective analysis, that the insurer knew, or recklessly
disregarded information that would allow it to know, that it lacked
a reasonable basis for denying the insured's claim for
benefits.