On September 18, the Court of Federal Claims (COFC) issued a decision in Multimedia
Environmental Compliance Group JV v. United States, denying a
bid protest that challenged the Small Business Administration's
(SBA's) Office of Hearings and Appeals (OHA) ruling on joint
venture eligibility.
The case reinforces SBA's insistence that
mentor-protégé joint venture agreements (JVAs) must
not only include the required provisions under 13 C.F.R. §
125.8 but also clearly establish that the small business
protégé, not the mentor, maintains real and practical
control over contract performance.
Background
The dispute arose from a Navy procurement for environmental
compliance engineering services, issued in June 2022 as a total
small business set-aside. Multimedia Environmental Compliance Group
JV (Multimedia), formed under SBA's
mentor-protégé program, submitted a proposal. After a
competitor, Acacia7 JV, filed a size protest, the SBA Area Office
determined that