As the economic crisis impairs the value of commercial
mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) that collateralize loans to real
estate investment trusts (REITs) to finance their investments,
there is the prospect of increased margin calls, requiring REITs to
provide additional funds to make up shortfalls in value. The case
of AG MIT CMO, LLC et al. v. Royal Bank of Canada et al.,
No. 20-2547 (S.D.N.Y.), which recently settled, is worth examining
for its echoes of the past and some important lessons going forward
for REITs regarding the valuation of collateral and enforcement of
rights under repurchase agreements.
AG vs. RBC
The litigation arose in late March when RBC issued such margin
calls to AG. RBC then sought to auction off $11 million of the
REIT's CMBS, which prompted AG to commence proceedings against
the bank, seeking a temporary restraining order and preliminary
injunction to prevent what it described as an
"opportunistic" fire sale of its assets.