On December 18, 2024, the Montana Supreme Court ruled in the
case of Held v. Montana, finding that the Montana Environmental Policy
Act ("MEPA") violated the state's constitution. In
the midst of great change to the federal energy and
environmental policy landscape, the landmark Held ruling
established a potential blueprint for youth climate litigation
success at the state level. However, just three months later, the
nearby Utah Supreme Court dismissed a case that was, in many ways,
a protégé of Held.
The litigation in question was Natalie R. v. State of
Utah, a case filed by seven youth plaintiffs on March
15, 2022. In their complaint, the plaintiffs accused the State of
Utah, Governor Spencer Cox, and others involved in developing the
state's energy policy of "maximizing, promoting, and
systematically authorizing fossil fuel development in the state as
a matter of official state policy, codified in statute."
Plaintiffs argued that, through its fossil fuel