On Friday, May 26, 2015, a closely divided Texas Supreme Court
issued McGinnes Industrial Maintenance Corp. v. The Phoenix
Insurance Co., No. 14-0465, (Tex., June 26, 2015), holding
that a demand letter from the EPA to a potentially responsible
party ("PRP") under CERCLA and administrative proceedings
under CERCLA constitute a "suit" that triggers an
insurer's obligations under a CGL policy.
The facts in McGinnes are straightforward and, with
very little tweaking, could describe hundreds of Superfund sites
and thousands of PRPs. In the 1960s, McGinnes dumped pulp and paper
mill waste sludge into disposal pits along the San Jacinto River
near Houston, Texas. The EPA began investigating the site in 2005,
and in 2007 sent a "section 104(e) letter" demanding 32
categories of information from McGinnes concerning its activities
at the San Jacinto River site. The section 104(e) letter threatened
McGinnes with penalties of up to $32,500 per day if it did not
comply.