A Missouri court recently highlighted how difficult it is to
establish the divisibility of harm exception to joint and several
liability in cases under the Comprehensive Environmental Response,
Compensation, and Liability Act, commonly known as CERCLA. In doing
so, the United States District Court for the Western District of
Missouri rejected divisibility arguments and imposed joint and
several liability in Short Creek Development v. MFA
Incorporated, No 22-05021, 2023 WL 8452430 (W.D. Mo. Dec. 6,
2023). The court systematically analyzed the requirements for
divisibility, making the opinion a useful template for future
divisibility claims.
Background
The environmental harm in Short Creek was
from a fertilizer plant that produced phosphogypsum as a byproduct,
which was stored onsite in a gypstack. Phosphogypsum is primarily
gypsum and phosphate, but it also contains arsenic, low-level
radionuclides, selenium, zinc, cadmium, fluoride, sodium,
potassium, chloride,