Two recent district court decisions add to the growing number of
courts granting motions to dismiss putative ERISA class actions
challenging defined contribution plan fees and investment
performance. These decisions from the Eastern District of New
York and the Eastern District of Wisconsin are the latest victories
for defendants at the motion to dismiss stage in this arena, and
come on the heels of multiple similar decisions in the Sixth and
Seventh Circuits (discussed
here,
here, and
here).
Gonzalez v. Northwell Health,
Inc., No. 20-cv-3256, 2022 WL 4639673
(E.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2022)
In Gonzalez, a participant in Northwell
Health's 403(b) plan sued plan fiduciaries on behalf of herself
and a proposed class of other participants, alleging that
defendants caused the plan to incur excessive recordkeeping fees
and imprudently retain certain investment options despite the
availability of cheaper and better performing alternatives.
In particular, plaintiff