In a 3-1 decision, the National Labor Relations Board (Board) in
Johnson Controls, Inc., 368 NLRB No. 20 (July 3, 2019),
adopted a new standard that applies to an employer's
anticipatory withdrawal of union recognition, and set forth a new
framework for determining whether a union has reacquired majority
status. The Board's new model settles majority status
disputes through a secret-ballot election when the employer and the
union both have evidence supporting their positions.
The Board's new standard overrules prior precedent that
permitted a union to defeat an employer's announced intent to
withdraw recognition in an unfair labor practice proceeding by
presenting evidence that the union reacquired majority status in
the period between the employer's anticipatory notice of
withdrawal and actual withdrawal. Instead, under the new
standard, evidence of a union's actual loss of majority
support, if received by an employer within 90 days prior to
contract expiration,