A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Eleventh Circuit appeared skeptical of an arbitration provision in
a legal technology company's employee stock ownership plan
(ESOP). The judges appeared unlikely to force arbitration after
hearing arguments in the Employee Retirement Security Insurance Act
(ERISA) lawsuit alleging that the company's ESOP shares were
undervalued in a plan termination. The case is Eboni
Williams et al. v. Gerald Shapiro et al., Case Number
24-11192, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh
Circuit.
A360 Holdings LLC, a360inc executives, and Argent Trust Co., the
ESOP trustee, appealed to the Eleventh Circuit after a Georgia
federal district court judge denied their motion to compel
arbitration in March 2024. A360 ESOP participants filed their
proposed class action lawsuit in September 2022, claiming that A360
bought almost 883,000 shares of the ESOP at a rate of $30 per
share. According to workers, the shares should have