We determined last time that Justice Cuellar tends to more
heavily question appellants than respondents in civil cases
regardless of how the majority is leaning. This time,
we're looking at the data for criminal cases.
Unlike civil cases, when Justice Cuellar joins the majority in
criminal cases, he follows the expected pattern – he more
heavily questions the party likely to lose. When he joins the
majority in an affirmance, he averages 2.38 questions to appellants
and 1.91 to respondents. When he joins the majority in a
reversal, he averages 3.6 to respondents, only 3 to
appellants. When he joins the majority in a mixed decision
– affirmed in part, reversed in part – it's almost
a wash: 1.68 questions to appellants, 1.77 to respondents.