Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 29 APRIL 2009

CMR: Recent jurisdictional Developments

HFW
HFW
Contributor
HFW

HFW

HFW is a sector-focused law firm with people who have a real passion for the sectors they work in,...

View firm profile
Explore more from HFW

In Hatzl v XL Insurance Co Limited [2009] All ER 212, the Court of Appeal considered the question of whether the English Court had jurisdiction to hear the claimant carrier's claim for negative declaratory relief.

United KingdomTransport
Justin Reynolds
Justin Reynolds

The Decision of the Court

In Hatzl v XL Insurance Co Limited [2009] All ER 212, the Court of Appeal considered the question of whether the English Court had jurisdiction to hear the claimant carrier's claim for negative declaratory relief. The only connection with England was the fact that the defendant, the subrogated cargo insurers, had their principal place of business in England. The claim itself arose out of the loss of goods carried between Austria and Italy, the consignor and carrier were Austrian and the consignee was Italian. On the face of it the only jurisdictions available under Art 31 CMR were Austria and Italy.

The Claimant argued that the word "defendant" in Art 31, should include not only the carrier, the consignee and consignor, but also any assignee of those parties, including insurers who were assignees under rights of subrogation, which on the facts of the case it was argued gave the English Court jurisdiction.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from