Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 23 MAY 2007

Judge Strikes Down Withholding Notice Clause In JCT Form

The payment and adjudication provisions of the Construction Act are compulsory in commercial relationships. They can be used in consumer contracts, but if they fall foul of EU consumer protection laws they may be struck down. This happened to the withholding provisions of the JCT Minor Works 1998 form in a recent case before the TCC.

United KingdomReal Estate and Construction
Nirada Griffith
Nirada Griffith

The payment and adjudication provisions of the Construction Act are compulsory in commercial relationships. They can be used in consumer contracts, but if they fall foul of EU consumer protection laws they may be struck down. This happened to the withholding provisions of the JCT Minor Works 1998 form in a recent case before the TCC.

Facts

A building contract was entered into on JCT MW 98 form. The employer was a residential occupier, i.e. a "consumer" for EU law purposes. He had no real opportunity to negotiate the contract. Nor was he aware of the withholding notice provisions. Nor did he have any involvement with the management of the project. The consumer withheld several interim payments from the contractor on account of delays and defects in the work, but without issuing withholding notices. The matter was referred to adjudication, where the contractor was successful, because a withholding notice had not been issued. The contractor applied to the court for enforcement of the

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from